A photo of the Personal Grazing Box from Martha's Vineyard Cheesery. Three types of cheese, one charcuterie, fresh and dried fruit, pickles, olives, and nuts. Over 6oz of cheese, plus all the accompaniments!
Image of the exterior of Catboat Coffee Co., a specialty beverage and culinary destination on Martha's Vineyard, and home to the Martha's Vineyard Cheesery cheese counter!

Curated Retail Selection

Visit our small-but-mighty cheese case inside Catboat Coffee Co.! Here we feature a selection of cheeses from small-scale American producers, focusing on those in the New England area. We also offer a variety of “friends of cheese” accompaniments such as charcuterie, preserves, crackers, and pickles.

Pre-Assembled Grazing Boxes

We offer a few different sizes of pre-assembled grazing boxes which include a variety of cheeses, meats, and accompaniments. 


  • We need at least 24 hours advance notice to ensure we have enough product on hand.
  • Grazing boxes do not come with crackers, but we are happy to include a box on the side as an add-on.
Martha's Vineyard Cheesery's Small Personal Grazing Box - PGB

Small Grazing Box

Perfect as a hearty meal for one or a share plate for two.

This 5” x 7” box includes three types of cheese, one type of meat (optional), and various accompaniments. 

Martha's Vineyard Cheesery's Medium Personal Grazing Box - PGB

Medium Grazing Box

Great for 4–6 people.

This 9” x 9” box includes four different types of cheese, three types of meat (optional), and various accompaniments.

Martha's Vineyard Cheesery's Large Personal Grazing Box - PGB

Large Grazing Box

Great for 8–12 people.

This 11” x 14” box includes five types of cheese, four types of meat (optional), and various accompaniments.

Catering Offerings

From large grazing table spreads, to cute little grazing cups, to cheese wheel cakes, our catering offerings bring cheesy goodness to events of all sizes. Fill out a catering inquiry form though the Catboat Coffee Co. website to start the conversation about how we can help elevate your next event!

Thoughtful Gift Boxes​

Want to give the gift of cheese, but in a way that doesn’t have to be immediately consumed? Look no further than our gift boxes! We put together a selection of cheese cuts, charcuterie, and accompaniments – all cheese in gift boxes can be substituted for “cheese certificates” that can be redeemed at Catboat Coffee Co. at a later time. Available in small, medium, and large sizes.

Cheesy Events & Educational Experiences​

Interested in hosting a “Cheese 101” class? How about a “Build Your Own Cheese Board” workshop? What about having a “Raclette Night” in the comfort of your own home? We’re happy to bring a cheesy event to you! Inquire today about these fun experiences.

Grilled Cheese Night!

Thursday, November 16